Long-term monitoring of stormwater runoff and water quality in urbanized watersheds of the greater Phoenix metropolitan area, ongoing since 2008
Publication date: 2020-09-09
Author(s):
- Dan Childers, Arizona State University
- Stevan Earl, Arizona State University
- Nancy Grimm, Arizona State University
- Rebecca Hale, Idaho State University
- Laura Turnbull, Durham University, Science Laboratories
Abstract:
Urbanization dramatically alters watershed ecosystem processes. Land-use change and anthropogenic activities contribute to increased inputs of nutrients and other materials, while changes to land cover alter hydrology and the corresponding movement of materials. These changes have ramifications for both watershed processes and downstream systems. The impacts of urbanization on aquatic systems are well-studied, and frequently encapsulated in the ‘urban stream syndrome’ (Walsh et al. 2005) that describes, among others, increased nutrient loading and stream flashiness. However, there is some evidence that aridland cities behave differently (Grimm et al. 2004, 2005), and the complex dynamics among catchment characteristics, storm attributes, and runoff in highly urbanized settings of the Southwest remains poorly understood.
To enhance our understanding of stormwater dynamics and watershed functioning in aridland, urban environments, the Central Arizona–Phoenix Long-Term Ecological Research (CAP LTER) program began monitoring stormwater runoff at the outflow of the Indian Bend Wash (IBW) in 2008. The IBW is a major drainage in the greater Phoenix metropolitan area, draining much of the City of Scottsdale, and a tributary to the Salt River. A model of soft engineering, the IBW as it runs through the City of Scottsdale is comprised largely of a series of artificial lakes, parks, paths, golf courses, ball fields and other non-structural elements designed with the dual roles of providing outdoor amenities to the City residents and as a floodplain. A unique biogeochemistry of this novel system is detailed by Roach et al. (2008), and Roach and Grimm (2011).
Stormwater sampling is conducted near the outflow of the IBW ~0.6 km above its confluence with the Salt River. The sampling location coincides with a permanent USGS gauging station (USGS 09512162 INDIAN BEND WASH AT CURRY ROAD, TEMPE, AZ) that provides corresponding discharge data. Automated stormwater sampling equipment (ISCO® 6700 automated pump sampler) is used to collect discrete stormwater samples throughout the hydrograph of most runoff-generating storms.
Data and expertise garnered by the stormwater monitoring near the outflow of the IBW helped pave the way for a more expansive stormwater research effort facilitated by a leveraged grant from the National Science Foundation (DEB-0918457, NSF Ecosystems, 2009-13). Through the Stormwater Nitrogen in Arizona (SNAZ) project, ten hierarchically nested urban stormwater catchments in Scottsdale and Tempe, AZ were instrumented with automated stormwater samplers (ISCO® 6700 automated pump samplers). A subset of those 11 locations were fitted with bubbler modules (ISCO® 720 bubbler modules) for quantifying water height (and subsequently discharge), and tipping-bucket rain gauges (ISCO® 674). The ten study catchments differed in type of stormwater infrastructure, spanning a continuum from highly engineered stormwater infrastructure in older residential areas to non-engineered washes in the desert, but not in land-use type (land use in all study catchments is predominantly residential). As per sampling near the outflow of the IBW, discrete stormwater samples were collected from most runoff-generating storms at the outflow of the 10 study catchments from the fall of 2010 through the summer 2012. Rainfall samples were collected at a subset of the locations during several storms to provide data that would contribute to an assessment of sources of materials in runoff. Results of this study are detailed by Hale et al. (2014a, 2014b). Sampling at most locations ceased at the end of the SNAZ award period, but the CAP LTER continues its long-term monitoring of runoff near the outflow of the IBW. Four new sites that drain into the Salt River were added in the winter of 2016. Three of the new sites are located near downtown Phoenix in the Rio Salado habitat restoration area, and the fourth catching runoff from numerous freeways and entering the Salt River channel above the Tempe Town Lake.
Grimm N.B., Arrowsmith J.R., Eisinger C., Heffernan J., MacLeod A., Lewis D.B., et al. (2004) Effects of urbanization on nutrient biogeochemistry of aridland streams. In: Geophysical Monograph Series. (Eds R.S. DeFries, G.P. Asner and R.A. Houghton), pp. 129–146. American Geophysical Union, Washington, D. C.
Grimm N.B., Sheibley R.W., Crenshaw C.L., Dahm C.N., Roach W.J. and Zeglin L.H. (2005) N retention and transformation in urban streams. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 24, 626–642.
Hale R.L., Turnbull L., Earl S., Grimm N., Riha K., Michalski G., et al. (2014a) Sources and Transport of Nitrogen in Arid Urban Watersheds. Environmental Science & Technology 48, 6211–6219.
Hale R.L., Turnbull L., Earl S.R., Childers D.L. and Grimm N.B. (2014b) Stormwater Infrastructure Controls Runoff and Dissolved Material Export from Arid Urban Watersheds. Ecosystems 18, 62–75.
Roach W.J. and Grimm N.B. (2011) Denitrification mitigates N flux through the stream–floodplain complex of a desert city. Ecological Applications 21, 2618–2636.
Roach W.J., Heffernan J.B., Grimm N.B., Arrowsmith J.R., Eisinger C. and Rychener T. (2008) Unintended consequences of urbanization for aquatic ecosystems: a case study from the arizona desert. BioScience 58, 715–727.
Walsh C.J., Roy A.H., Feminella J.W., Cottingham P.D., Groffman P.M. and Morgan II R.P. (2005) The urban stream syndrome: current knowledge and the search for a cure. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 24, 706–723.
Keywords:
nutrients,
dissolved organic carbon,
dissolved organic nitrogen,
dissolved inorganic nitrogen,
rivers,
discharge,
water chemistry,
particulates,
nitrate,
nitrite,
ammonium,
anions,
cations,
chloride,
phosphorus,
nitrogen,
specific conductivity,
urban,
runoff,
watersheds,
total dissolved nitrogen water and fluxes,
parks and rivers,
movement of organic matter,
movement of inorganic matter stormwater,
catchment cap lter,
cap,
caplter,
central arizona phoenix long term ecological research,
arizona,
az,
arid land
Temporal Coverage:
2008-01-29 to 2019-11-25
Geographic Coverage:
Geographic Description: CAP LTER study area
Bounding Coordinates:
Longitude:-112.082 to -111.865
Latitude:33.6149 to 33.3745
Contact:
Information Manager, Central Arizona–Phoenix LTER,
Arizona State University,Global Institute of Sustainability,Tempe
caplter.data@asu.edu
Methods used in producing this dataset:
Show
## sample collection and analysis
Stormwater samples are collected from the field sampling location within 12 hours of a storm, and transported to CAP LTER laboratory facilities at Arizona State University (ASU) for processing and analysis. The suite of analytes and the instruments used to perform analyses have changed during the course of the monitoring. Analysis and instrument details are included in the analysis table that is available for download. In all cases, dissolved analytes reflect analysis following filtration through ashed (550 degree Celsius, ≥1 h) GF/F (0.7-µm pore size) filters. Similarly, particulates reflect analysis of materials retained (retentate) following filtration through GF/F filters. Holding times and preservation methods are in accordance with guidelines established by American Public Health Association (APHA. 1998. Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater, 20th edn. APHA, NY). Identical methods are employed for the sampling and chemical analysis of rainfall samples, except that only a single, bulk sample of rainfall was collected for any given site/storm.
## discharge
Except at IBW where discharge is available from the USGS, water stage-height was measured with ISCO® 720 bubbler modules that were installed in concrete channels, box sections, or pipes to facilitate development of depth-discharge rating curves. Rating curves were developed using the Manning's Equation to calculate discharge (Q) from the flow-stage measurements. At some locations, irregularities in the ground-surface profile or aberrant water-height values resulted in unrealistic discharge estimates. Both the raw discharge values as calculated from water height and the Manning's Equation (discharge.discharge) and these corrected discharge estimates (discharge.discharge_edited) are included in the discharge table that is available for download.
Data Files (8) :
Tabular:
624_analytes_04c4e211faef1dc9dbbf59297c34fb23.csv
Description: catalog and details of water chemistry analytes measured as part of CAP LTER stormwater monitoring
Column |
Description |
Type |
Units |
analysis |
analyte quantified
|
string |
|
description |
analyte description
|
string |
|
units |
unit of measure
|
string |
|
instrument |
analytical instrument
|
string |
|
Tabular:
624_discharge_555b240842f057afacfaddb343ca2915.csv
Description: discharge at CAP LTER stormwater sampling sites
Temporal Coverage: 2010-08-04 to 2019-12-04
Column |
Description |
Type |
Units |
discharge_location |
sampling location identifier
|
string |
|
discharge_datetime |
measurement date and time
|
date |
Format: YYYY-MM-DD hh:mm:ss |
water_height |
water height above sensor
|
float |
meter |
raw_discharge |
discharge (Q) estimated from Manning equation
|
float |
literPerSecond |
edited_discharge |
corrections to raw_discharge
|
float |
literPerSecond |
Tabular:
624_particulates_d74c5c136089685185464ab21c20ba23.csv
Description: mass of particulates in stormwater during runoff-generating storms at CAP LTER stormwater sampling sites
Temporal Coverage: 2008-01-29 to 2019-09-26
Column |
Description |
Type |
Units |
runoff_location |
sampling location identifier
|
string |
Enumeration:
-
Ave7th: Salt River at Seventh Avenue Avenue
-
CB: Indian Bend Wash at Camelback Road
-
centralNorth: Salt River at Central Avenue (north)
-
centralSouth: Salt River at Central Avenue (south)
-
IBW: Indian Bend Wash at Curry Road
-
KP: Kiwanis Park in Tempe AZ
-
LM: Indian Bend Wash at Lake Marguerite
-
Price: drain into the Salt River near Price Road
-
SGC: Indian Bend Wash at Silverado Golf Course
|
runoff_datetime |
collection date and time
|
date |
Format: YYYY-MM-DD hh:mm:ss |
replicate |
sample replicate number
|
float |
number |
filter_wt |
weight of clean, ashed filter
|
float |
gram |
filter_dry_wt |
dry filter weight
|
float |
gram |
vol_filtered |
volume of sample filtered
|
float |
milliliter |
filter_ash_wt |
ashed weight of filter
|
float |
gram |
data_qualifier |
data qualifier flag
|
string |
|
comments |
technician comments regarding analysis of that sample
|
string |
|
blank |
boolean value indicating whether the sample is a blank
|
string |
Enumeration:
-
FALSE: indicates sample is not a blank
-
TRUE: indicates sample is a blank
|
Tabular:
624_rainfall_chemistry_9d84a10dc5d55a947c2ff5ff813e420c.csv
Description: water chemistry of collected rainfall at CAP LTER stormwater sampling sites
Temporal Coverage: 2010-09-22 to 2012-07-30
Column |
Description |
Type |
Units |
rain_location |
sampling location identifier
|
string |
Enumeration:
-
SGC: Silverado Golf Course
|
rain_datetime |
collection date
|
date |
Format: YYYY-MM-DD |
replicate |
sample replicate number
|
float |
number |
analysis |
analyte quantified
|
string |
Enumeration:
-
CaD_ICP: dissolved calcium (ICP)
-
ClD_LACHAT: dissolved chloride (LACHAT)
-
DOC_TOC: dissolved organic carbon
-
NaD_ICP: dissolved sodium (ICP)
-
NH4_LACHAT: ammonium-nitrogen (LACHAT)
-
NO3D_LACHAT: dissolved nitrate-nitrogen (Lachat)
-
NO3T_TOC_TN: total nitrogen by combustion analysis TOC/TN
-
NO3T_TRAACS: total dissolved nitrogen (TRAACS); NH4-N, NO3-N and DON are oxidized to NO3-N and measured together
-
PO4D_LACHAT: dissolved phosphorus (LACHAT)
-
PO4T_TRAACS: total phosphorus (TRAACS)
-
ZnD_ICP: dissolved zinc (ICP-OES)
|
concentration |
concentration of analyte
|
float |
milligramPerLiter |
data_qualifier |
data qualifier flag
|
string |
|
comments |
comments regarding sample
|
string |
|
Tabular:
624_rainfall_ed7a47e1562b0521d3949a4b3233f8ff.csv
Description: depth of precipitation as measured by tipping bucket rain gauge at CAP LTER stormwater sampling sites
Temporal Coverage: 2010-05-11 to 2012-08-28
Column |
Description |
Type |
Units |
rain_location |
location short code
|
string |
|
rain_datetime |
measurement date and time
|
date |
Format: YYYY-MM-DD hh:mm:ss |
rain_quantity |
precipitation amount
|
float |
millimeter |
Tabular:
624_runoff_chemistry_881895037a2e1789a54ee9b29c1dbdad.csv
Description: stormwater runoff chemistry during runoff-generating storms at CAP LTER stormwater sampling sites
Temporal Coverage: 2008-01-29 to 2019-11-25
Column |
Description |
Type |
Units |
runoff_location |
sampling location identifier
|
string |
Enumeration:
-
Ave7th: Salt River at Seventh Avenue Avenue
-
CB: Indian Bend Wash at Camelback Road
-
centralNorth: Salt River at Central Avenue (north)
-
centralSouth: Salt River at Central Avenue (south)
-
IBW: Indian Bend Wash at Curry Road
-
KP: Kiwanis Park in Tempe AZ
-
LM: Indian Bend Wash at Lake Marguerite
-
Price: drain into the Salt River near Price Road
-
SGC: Indian Bend Wash at Silverado Golf Course
|
runoff_datetime |
date and time of sample collection
|
date |
Format: YYYY-MM-DD hh:mm:ss |
blank |
boolean value indicating whether the sample is a blank
|
string |
Enumeration:
-
FALSE: indicates sample is not a field blank
-
TRUE: indicates sample is a field blank
|
sample_comments |
technician comments pertaining to site conditions or sample details
|
string |
|
ph |
pH of the sample
|
float |
dimensionless |
replicate |
sample replicate number
|
float |
number |
analysis_name |
analysis type
|
string |
Enumeration:
-
CaD_FLAME_AA: dissolved calcium (FLAME AA)
-
CaD_ICP: dissolved calcium (ICP)
-
ClD_LACHAT: dissolved chloride (LACHAT)
-
DOC_TOC: dissolved organic carbon
-
KD_ICP: dissolved potassium (ICP)
-
MgD_ICP: dissolved magnesium (ICP)
-
NaD_ICP: dissolved sodium (ICP)
-
NH4_LACHAT: ammonium-nitrogen (LACHAT)
-
NiD_ICP: dissolved nickel (ICP-OES)
-
NO2D_LACHAT: dissolved nitrite-nitrogen (LACHAT)
-
NO3D_IC: dissolved nitrate-nitrogen (IC)
-
NO3D_LACHAT: dissolved nitrate-nitrogen (Lachat)
-
NO3T_AQ2: total nitrogen (AQ2)
-
NO3T_TOC_TN: total nitrogen by combustion analysis TOC/TN
-
NO3T_TRAACS: total dissolved nitrogen (TRAACS): NH4-N and NO3-N and DON are oxidized to NO3-N and measured together
-
PbD_ICP: dissolved lead (ICP-OES)
-
PO4D_LACHAT: dissolved phosphorus (LACHAT)
-
PO4T_AQ2: total phosphorus (AQ2)
-
PO4T_LACHAT: total phosphorus (LACHAT)
-
PO4T_TRAACS: total phosphorus (TRAACS)
-
SO4D_IC: dissolved sulfate (IC)
-
ZnD_ICP: dissolved zinc (ICP-OES)
|
analysis_concentration |
concentration of analyte
|
float |
milligramPerLiter |
analysis_data_qualifier |
quality control flag pertaining to sample analysis
|
string |
|
analysis_comments |
technician comments pertaining to specific analysis
|
string |
|
Spatial Vector:
624_indian_bend_wash_catchments.kml
Description: The location and configuration of watersheds that are or have been sampled as part of the CAP LTER's research on stormwater monitoring in the greater Phoenix metropolitan area. Catchments for sampling locations along the Salt River (centralNorth, centralSouth, Ave7th) and Price have not been delineated by the CAP LTER.
Horizontal Coordinate System:GCS_WGS_1984
Geometry Type: Polygon
Column |
Description |
Type |
Units |
Name |
name of catchment as it corresponds to name of sampling location at the outflow
|
string |
|
Spatial Vector:
624_sampling_location.kml
Description: CAP LTER stormwater sampling locations
Horizontal Coordinate System:GCS_WGS_1984
Geometry Type: Point
Column |
Description |
Type |
Units |
latitude |
latitude of sampling location
|
float |
degree |
longitude |
longitude of sampling location
|
float |
degree |
Name |
sampling location identifier
|
string |
|
description |
sampling location description
|
string |
|